Much of the music we hear and play is over-orchestrated. The result
of this superabundance of musical sounds is a neutral, bland, lifeless
gray without contrast, tonal variety, or clarity of line. How can a
conductor or arranger help his group achieve a clean and varied sound,
deal with obvious intonation problems and still maintain a balanced
ensemble? I have found the following ideas to be quite successful
with school instrumental groups.
Reductions
Reduce the number of players on the high flute/clarinet parts
to improve intonation (flutes and clarinets tend to overblow
in their high register). Ask the clarinets and flutes to play
softer as they progress upward, and/or reduce the number of players
to two per part in soft passages. Take the time to determine
which players play in tune with one another. You will be that
much closer to achieving good intonation and proper blend. Faulty
embouchures and a variety of instrumental brands are factors
not quickly or easily overcome.
Do not have the saxophones double the brass parts when a pure
brass sound is desired. The sound of the saxophones tends to
dull or soften the edge and brilliance of the brass. For the
same reason do not double the bass or contrabass clarinet with
the tuba in purely brass passages.
Do not let the saxes play horn cues unless the horns cannot
handle their parts. The thick, oily sound of the saxes tends
to thicken the horn line and often creates intonation problems.
Use only one oboe or bassoon on unison lines to eliminate differences
in intonation among young players. Or, try writing an accompanying
line that moves in thirds with the melody; . Use only one saxophone
player on high unison lines, since student saxophonists have
difficulty playing in tune in this range.
Put only one or two trumpets (cornets) on very high and loud
passages. You will maintain your players' endurance and soften
obvious intonation problems.
Use bells only for special effects and do not allow them to
play oboe or flute lines. The ear quickly tires of certain sounds
when they are used for long periods. Bells, percussion, piccolo,
woodwind trills, and full-sounding "safe" tutti sections
become especially tiresome.
Eliminate the bass clarinets from fast-moving bass lines. The
instrument thickens the line, makes it sluggish, and causes the
music to drag.
Tubas usually play too often. Look for spots where they can
be omitted. The tuba has a tendency to "blot out" some
upper woodwind partials and the resulting sound is less brilliant,
especially in softer passages. If the tubas are not carefully
tuned and are allowed to play sharp, the entire band sounds flat.
Be sure that a reinforcing line at the octave
is not
heavier
in weight and intensity that the fundamental tone.
Additions
Add one triangle note (a small triangle and thin striker) to
fermatas in slow-moving pieces, or to climax points. It provides
a lift and a sparkle to the sound, and brightens up the section.
Triangle rolls (inside the closed corner of the triangle) are
effective when combined with woodwind trills.
For added brilliance, double (an octave higher) a trumpet line
with a piccolo, flute or bells. Be sure that the reinforcing
line at the octave is not heavier in weight and intensity than
the fundamental tone. Remember that bells tend to take the edge
off staccato passages.
Add the deep sonority of the contrabass or contra-alto clarinet
to works published before about 1950 by doubling the tuba or
string bass line. This will add firmness, volume, and resonance
to the music. The contrabass clarinet can be substituted for
the tuba in soft passages. (The second section of Vaughan Williams' "Folk
Song Suite" is a beautiful example of creative writing for
the contrabass clarinet.
Modifications
Rescore fast legato trombone passages for a baritone horn or
tenor sax. These passages are particularly difficult for student
players.
Bells played at a rapid rate tend to sound messy
and blurred. The following example shows how one might modify
a typical bell part to outline a musical idea.
Horns tend to respond slightly later than either trumpets or
trombones, especially when all have the same rhythmic figures.
To achieve a crisper, cleaner response modify the horn part as
follows:
Low, harsh-sounding oboe parts (with low D, C, B, Bb) can be
given to a clarinet (If the line is legato) or to trumpet with
a straight mute (if the line is staccato).
Rapid staccato passages around the "break" of the
clarinet can be given to the trumpets.
Generally, mark sustaining parts one dynamic level lower that
staccato parts. Legato lines have more carrying power.
To avoid fatigue, rewrite the horns so they can alternate when
similar passages repeat.
Simplify quick-moving rhythms in low ranges for the larger instruments.
Note how the following unison lower brass passage has been simplified
for the tuba.
Rearrange works to feature solo and small ensemble playing within
the large group. Prominent parts help build both tone and the
student's confidence as the players are forced out of the "protective
custody" of the larger ensemble.Listening to numerous big,
thick chords and full harmonic progressions is a tiring experience.
The impact of rich, full-sounding chords tends to obliterate
clarity of design and movement while pointing out the need for
music that is sufficiently transparent to allow different sections,
lines, and tonal colors to be heard. Perhaps the above suggestions
will help your groups achieve a clearer, cleaner sound. Isn't
it worth the time and effort to get rid of the gray?